Wow.. this Scholar debate between the powers-that-be and the people just won't stop.
Both sides are firing on all cylinders, to the extent that the Chairman of a stat board came out in defence of the type of courses that these scholars take.
To recap, one guy wrote in the paper that to make the grade, scholars take easy courses. And then a whole cacophony of comments and letters flew onto the Straits Times for about 2 weeks now.
This is my own personal take:
I am not a bright spark. On the contrary, I think I suck most times when it comes to studies. Not that I am dumb, but I just don't like to study a subject unless I know why I am doing it for.
Take Differential Equations. The first time I took it, I got a D because I just couldn't understand why the heck I am learning the stuff. Then I progressed on to other subjects like control systems, electrical circuits etc and it was only then that I realized the value of Diff Eq.
During my second time round (trying to raise my GPA), the course was thought by a Math prof, who for some reason was also doing his MSc in Electrical Engineering. So a lot of the Diff Eq stuff was taught with an engineering spin, which made sense as 80% of the class were from Engineering. And I scored an A.
Now I also know a lot of foreign students who would just go to class, and then the library and then home. They'd scored 4.00, or perfect A's while undertaking a higher than normal load of classes. And then they went home.
Me, I was surprised I made it to Grad School as my school had a 2nd proviso: I had to maintain a 3.0 in my junior and senior year (which I did by a pip). I took the time to participate in the collegiate elections, helped organize a multi-national student event for returning students from SE Asia, including handling the consulate staff from the various countries, participated in a engineering presentation competition organized by ASME (American Society of Mechanical Engineers) - I am quite pleased as I was the only foreign student and I won 3rd place. I also became Chairman of the college chapter of ASME.
I sang in an choir made of international students, learnt songs (though easy ones) from Japan, and Zambia. Participated in the International Student Organization and also played football on weekends with friends, local and foreign alike.
So what?
I am definitely not the scholar type
But I must say that I have benefitted a lot from my CCA's.
Why is this important?
Because I have seen smart people (scholar types) that can't work in an industry setting because they just can't communicate properly, or are unable to adapt to the surroundings.
On the other hand, I personally know scholars who are not the typical run-of-the-mill scholars and they represent Singapore best hope of a future that is not set on "doing it this way just because my forefathers have been doing since time immemorial".
I just hope these scholars does not conform to the government bodies that they work for and I find this to more troubling as it is not the scholar, but the systems that makes or breaks the future.