Tuesday, March 21, 2006

Katak Bawah Tempurung

aka Frog Under the Well.

Today I read an article on Star Online titled: "Don't Interfere in Islam, Non-Muslims Warned"

I was dismayed as I think cross- race and religion relation (and indirectly - discussions) in Malaysia just took like 10 steps backward.

What precipitated this was that Murthy case where he secretly converted to Islam and yet to his wife and kids, still lived the life of a Hindu. So after he died, there was a contest by both sides as to whether he was Muslim or Hindu. The civil courts refused to hear the case. Lest to say we know who lost prevailed.

Then a couple of weeks later, an old grandmother passed away. She was born a Malay (thus Muslim) but had given up Islam a long time ago and live as a Buddhist. her applications to give up her religion was either not answered definitively nor rejected. This time, the Sya'riah court approved her application (or rather her family's) to be buried as a Buddhist.

There is a feeling that it was to appease the non-Muslims of Malaysia. Who was this grandma?? Who was Murthy? He was the bloke that climbed Everest and was one of those who hoisted the Jalur Gemilang for the world to see. In view on how Malaysians love such press, of couse there is more "prestige" to consider Murthy one of their Muslim brothers (and not Malaysian brothers - which then all of us could be proud of)

Then recently, at least in Singapore, there was an article that questioned which court system would protect converts? Would it be the Civil or the Sya'riah courts? THey noted several cases of converts converting for all the wrong reasons (like marrying an idiot or the potential of marrying an idiot - who coincidently happened to be Muslim) and their cases are in limbo as there was supposed to be this anti-apostecy law that would prevent any Muslim from leaving the religion.

And it would be the most likely outcome that the Syariah would rule on behalf of the religion and stike down these converts' applicaiton to renounce their religion.

So right now, any hope of a sensible discussion on the true state of matters in Malaysia is effectively closed down. Wow. So much for multi-cultural, all accomodating religious state of being in Malaysia. Sound like pure bullshit PR to me.

And I think the government is pandering to the histerics of a certain quarter in the government in their effort to out-Islamize PAS. I see this is part of crutch mentality that exists in Malaysia. Touch on Bumi privileges, or Islam, there they go shouting, don't talk about this, or you don't know about that etc etc. Where is the rational discussion? Zip. Nada!

Don't get me wrong, I have lots of Muslim friends and we respect each other's religion. I just feel that everyone must be able to discuss this sensitive subject with a level-headed approach and not sweep everything under the sedition act carpet.

Come one. Don't be so Katak Di Bawah Tempurung.

technorati tags: , , , ,