I read with great interest the recent news article about a think-tank, ASLI, who published a report that the Bumiputera portion of the Malaysian economic pie is 40+ % instead of the government sanctioned 18.7%.
Then more interestingly, the UMNO politicos started to demean the entire Bumiputera race, not by saying YES WE HAVE DONE IT!!!, but instead chose a negative tract, much like saying WE'RE NOT ABLE TO MAKE IT.
While I have not taken the time to run through the fine print, this I can gather from the ASLI report.
1) ASLI measured the equity pie based on market valuation, and not on par value.
Market Valuation reflects the true value of the equity, however, it will fluctuate as the stock market goes up and down. Measuring on par value alone is not adequate as if the owner of the stock sells out to the market, how would the concensus measure the profit or difference made between realized value and par.
Even when papers such as Forbes values the richest people in so and so region, they always market value and not par value.
Verdict: ASLI.
2) ASLI's survey also include GLCs.
To be quite honest, GLCs by virtue of being partially owned by the government are mainly bumiputera shareholders anyways. So to remove GLCs from the equation skews the percentage calculations.
Verditc: ASLI.
3) The Bumiputera owned economic pie has not grown from its 18.7% share for the past 20 years.
C'mon. You have gotta be kidding me.
Do you mean to say that after 20 years of affirmative action, the Bumiputera businessmen still need help. Does that mean that in another 20 years, the economic share of these Bumiputera still stands at 18.7%?
I seriously think something is wrong with this equation. The country has enjoyed many years of economic growth, and we see Bumiputera businessmen getting rich and staying in villas and driving Mercs, then why is there still that 18.7% share?
Is the government saying that there is a disparity between the 1st tier Bumi businessmen and the 3rd tier Bumi businessmen.
Then THIS should be the problem to be addressed, NOT how much equity the Bumis own on the overall.
In actuality, I think the government should be looking at ALL 3rd tier businessmen and look into how to close the gap between the super-rich and the trying to make it in business types. The super rich can take care of themselves and definitely should not play the "I'M MALAY SO HELP ME", or the "I'M CHINESE SO HELP ME" (which never happens anyways).
C'mon Pak Lah, perhaps it is not politically expedient to embrace the study wholeheartedly, but at least, sit down with ASLI or another independent party to study the Bumiputera equity pie and understand who needs help the most.. and pls help those who need the help, regardless of race or religion as afterall, we're all Malaysians.
technorati tags:bumiputera, ASLI, UMNO, Pak Lah, economic pie, affirmative action, business
Blogged with Flock