Tuesday, July 29, 2008

Philip Yeo article

I wanted to send this out, but someone got left inside my draft folder. Better late then never

I read with great interest the article in today's ST about Phillip Yeo. I've had the opportunity to work in one of the organizations he headed, so I have see how he works. No first hand but perhaps second-hand.

I have always known him to be one who is unorthodox in how he does things, and I must admit, it was challenging to work within the OB markers that he had set.

However, I must qualify that his style may not necessarily work in every situation. I believe he was able to work it his way because he had a good mentor who allowed him to stretch his wings, and his mentor must have acted as protector to his potential detractors.

I can say this first hand as I have tried to work outside of the box, or better yet, remove the box completely. Alas, poor me, I was not a director level employee, so there were still many layers between myself and the top guy. My big boss was also one who did not like working within the box, but he brings his own weight to bear.

Unfortunately for me, I worked within the confines that my big boss had provided me with and it was still larger than what my counterparts (mostly people more senior - thus more ingrained than me) could accommodate. And as such, many of my recommendations presented during my project presentations were met with snickers as well as off-hand, behind-the-back and less than generous remarks, and worst of all, by people I had high respect for.

As such I would say this.
1) He did wonders in EDB because he essentially started it from scratch, thus he had a free hand in drafting the blueprint for the future of the organization
2) His success in A*STAR was purely limited to success (even then I would quantify as limited success) within the Biomedical sector. I believe he could have done more, had more impact, had more success if he had "cleaned the house" completely when he took over and redesignated NSTB to A*STAR. I guess at that time, his focus was purely to start-up the BMS side of research and thus he left the other half of A*STAR alone. And I firmly believe he should have stayed longer than 5 years. He stayed in EDB for more than 20 years, and in science and research, the outcome can only be measure in those timeframes (ie 20 years)

Time will only tell if the monies poured in by the government into Biopolis would bear fruit. I think it will, but I am unsure.

But in essence, it is a wonder how a guy like him was able to survive the bureaucracy that is the civil service where for most, there is perhaps only one thought, one mantra if you will that they bring with them daily to work: do not screw up. But with such attitudes, then the people and some scientists will not be challenged to do more than beyond what is required because the more they do, the more likely they will screw up.

So most proposals will be discussed via committee and International advisory boards, where the decision (and the blame if it all goes shitters) can be spread amongst the members of the committee, who are mostly prominent people, so they will be sort of like teflon coated anyways. Any hardcharging young 'un will stand out like a nail to be hammered down with the rest of his or her cohort.

So now you know why there will only be one Phillip Yeo and why he cannot be cloned. Because his prospective clones have all been zapped into unthinking robots who remain part of the service, and those who have not been transformed 100% into those unthinking robots have all escaped into the private sector because then they can stretch their wings without being hammered silly by the do not screw up boss.